Private Foundation (PF)
A 501(c)(3) organization your family controls. More paperwork and stricter rules than a donor-advised fund, but the family gets full governance, can hire family members, and can fund scholarships and operating programs. Typical minimum scale to justify the overhead: ~$5M+.
A Private Foundation () is a 501(c)(3) charitable organization funded and controlled by a single family (or a small donor group). The foundation is an actual separate legal entity — usually a nonprofit corporation chartered in a state or a charitable trust — with its own board, its own tax ID, and its own annual IRS filings (Form 990-PF).
What you get that a donor-advised fund () does not: (1) full governance — the family board makes the grants, not a sponsor; (2) ability to run operating programs (scholarship programs, direct charitable activities, fellowships); (3) ability to pay reasonable compensation to family members serving as officers or directors; (4) ability to invest in mission-aligned businesses (program-related investments under § 4944); (5) permanent family charitable platform across generations.
What you give up vs. a DAF: (1) much higher administrative load — annual 990-PF filing, minimum-distribution requirement (5% of net investment assets annually under IRC § 4942), excise tax on net investment income (1.39% under § 4940), self-dealing restrictions (§ 4941), taxable-expenditure rules (§ 4945); (2) lower AGI deduction limits — 30% for cash (vs. 60% for DAF), 20% for appreciated stock (vs. 30%); (3) setup legal costs of $5K-$25K; (4) ongoing legal + accounting of $10K-$50K+ per year.
Rule of thumb: below roughly $5M, the administrative overhead eats too much of the charitable dollar, and a DAF is better. Above $10M-$20M, the governance and programmatic flexibility of a PF usually wins. The in-between zone is a judgment call — many families use BOTH (PF for large strategic gifts + DAF for routine giving).
Tagged 🔴 — forming, maintaining, and complying with PF rules requires a tax attorney and a 990-PF-experienced CPA.
State-specific notes
PFs are subject to annual minimum distribution (5% of net investment assets under § 4942), excise tax on net investment income (§ 4940), self-dealing prohibitions (§ 4941), excess business holdings limits (§ 4943), jeopardizing investment limits (§ 4944), and taxable expenditure restrictions (§ 4945).
Virginia private foundations typically organize as Virginia nonstock corporations under § 13.1-803 et seq. The Virginia Office of the Attorney General — Charitable Solicitation Division regulates solicitations; annual registration required if soliciting in Virginia.
West Virginia private foundations organize as nonprofit corporations under W. Va. Code Chapter 31E. Charitable-registration oversight is in the WV Secretary of State's office.
Private foundations formed in Alabama are typically organized as nonprofit corporations under the Alabama Nonprofit Corporation Law (Ala. Code Title 10A, Chapter 3) or as charitable trusts under Ala. Code § 19-3B-405. Federal PF rules (IRC §§ 4940-4945) control excise-tax and self-dealing exposure; Alabama offers no separate state PF overlay. Alabama charitable registration with the Alabama Attorney General's Consumer Interest Division may be required under Ala. Code § 13A-9-70 et seq.
References
Prepare your attorney-intake packet
This strategy requires licensed counsel to draft. Use the builder to capture your facts, intent, and questions in an attorney-ready packet — you'll hand it to the lawyer who actually drafts the trust or agreement. This is not a legal instrument and does not create an attorney-client relationship.